Wikia

EarthBound Wiki

Talk:Pokey Minch

1,403pages on
this wiki

Back to page

This is the talk page for discussing the subject of or improvements to the Pokey Minch article.

  • Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (~~~~).
  • Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
  • New to EarthBound Wiki? Welcome! Ask questions, get answers.
  • Be polite
  • Assume good faith
  • No personal attacks
  • Be welcoming

Pokey or Porky?Edit

uhhhhh his real name is porky-207.241.247.30 17:10, 19 May 2008 (UTC)

No. The literal translation of his Japanese name is Porky. This is an English wiki, and as such everything is referred to by its English title, unless there is none which is the case for some characters and the PSI abilities of Mother 3. Ninten Vixen Ana Windstorm Lloyd 18:11, 19 May 2008 (UTC)

Actually im right his name is Pokey in U.S. because of mistranslation becuase the japanesse could'nt spell Porky in japanesse letters so it sounded like "Po-ki".Nintedo of america changed it when the brot SSBB to the U.S. name.-207.241.247.30 16:57, 21 May 2008 (UTC)

Yeah that's true, but in virtually every aspect of the English version of Mother universe, the character's name has always been mentioned as "Pokey," with the only exception being his appearance in Brawl. One appearance as a boss in a series that compiles numerous characters from other gaming universes, while remaining canon to those series' only half the time is not notable enough to refer to him as "Porky," even if the name he has come to be known as was was the result of a mistransliteration. Ninten Vixen Ana Windstorm Lloyd 19:48, 21 May 2008 (UTC)

How do you think in brawl he got out of the absolutely safe capsule? in the subspace emissary he is in his bed-mecha did master hand got him out with some hocous pokess?-207.241.247.30 16:43, 23 May 2008 (UTC)

I don't know, but like I said the Super Smash Bros. series remains canon to the featured characters' original series' only half the time. There's at least a dozen examples of inconsistencies between the characters' official selves and their Smash versions. Ninten Vixen Ana Windstorm Lloyd 16:59, 23 May 2008 (UTC)

I think Pokey was jelous of ness cuase he had a loving family and pokey had an abusive one and he ran away travled through time and ruled an empire and brainwashing pepole that he was great mabe all he wanted was atenttion-71.169.39.194 16:23, 20 June 2008 (UTC)

Hold on a second...doesn't all the pig-related stuff make a LOT more sense if his name is Porky? Though I guess since the wordplay didn't exist in the Japanese language, that's probably a coincidence or something...but what a coincidence o_O. Unless I've missed something; I suspect I have. Someone enlighten me? :P A.K.A : Evil Overlord of Randomness. 11:19, 12 December 2008 (UTC)
The wordplay would make more sense if he were referred to as 'Porky', but this is a wiki directed towards an English audience. Because of that, English sources take precedence over Japanese ones, regardless of whatever meaning was attempted to be conveyed in the original material. The only Mother game Pokey appears in that has been localized by Nintendo is EarthBound, however this adaption loses in translation the character's truly intended name. Super Smash Bros. Brawl uses the Japanese transliterations of Mother 3 material (Porky, Tazumili Village), and the English version of Mother 3 is an unofficial attempt to capture the most precise vision of an English Mother 3 (Tomato actually discusses in the project's production notes his inner conflict when making the decision which name to use for the translation). So again, because this is an English wiki, the name used in official English source material is used. The order of what takes precedence over what should go something like:
EarthBound (the only officially translated and marketed game in the series) → Earth Bound (or what most people call EarthBound Zero, officially translated into English but never marketed) → Mother 3 translation (unofficial, but developed by professionals and true to its foreign source) → Japanese games. Ninten Vixen Ana Windstorm Lloyd 03:26, 13 December 2008 (UTC)
And presumably EarthBound also beats out Super Smash Bros. Brawl...so basically, EarthBound being the only officially translated Mother game, gets precedence over everything, and he was Pokey in that. Righty, thanks! That clears quite a bit up ^_^ A.K.A : Evil Overlord of Randomness. 10:27, 13 December 2008 (UTC)

The Idea StealerEdit

I personally think Pokey stole too many ideas from Giygas. Play through Chapter 8 of Mother 3 and you'll see why.

Giygas, if he was included in the game, would have been so proud of him. Beta Knight 21:54, 3 February 2009 (UTC)

Well the gamemakers like referencing past games,so I can see why it's like that.

momEdit

did you guys know that in a restaurant in new pork city called "beauty and tasty" all the robots in there are designed after pokey's mother, i think you guys should add that to the article.

EsperEdit

Pokey does resemble the esper children of Akira--EsperPokey 11:31, September 12, 2009 (UTC)

Sad For Pokey Edit

When I saw that Pokey got stuck in a capsule for all eternity, I felt sad. If you seriously went "YAY!" when Pokey got locked in the capsule forever, you must be crazy. How would YOU like it if you had eternal life and got locked in a capsule until Year Infinity? 67.173.36.164 01:09, April 26, 2010 (UTC)


When i saw the capsule, i was like "O_o" and then i thought to myself "Hah, PSI Love Omega can break anything, along with Starstorm", but my plan backfired. D:

[[1]] 13:45, June 20, 2010 (UTC)


I can understand how mirable it is that Pokey will be living for eternity inside that capsule. I would rather kill him.

108.4.13.59 13:53, March 31, 2012 (UTC)eveezelda13

Honestly, it's not just the fact that he trapped himself in the Absolutely Safe Capsule; EVERYTHING about this kid makes me sad. How? I'll count the ways:

  1. Almost no friends.
  2. Neglectful and possibly abusive parents.
  3. Still wanted to be Ness' friend, even after he had become the Pig King.
  4. Seemed kinda misunderstood.

There. This is why I would not classify Porky as "evil" and why I'm sorry for him. YoungOtakuNerd (talk) 07:04, July 23, 2013 (UTC)

Name of Article Edit

Rekindling what appears to be an old debate, I wish to ask the members of EB wiki their opinion, though I'm already pretty sure about this. Now, in most cases I take the Mother 3 translations (see the PK Freeze page, for example) but the problem I have is, Pokey is never officially, canonically called Porky. Though Tomato's translation is brilliant, I simply cannot take it as official when an official translation has previously said Pokey. Brawl is non canon, however, so it referring to Pokey as Porky can also not be taken as official. I have made the tentative decision to keep the name as Pokey, and just use Porky in Mother 3 sections. If there is ever an official nintendo translation of Mother 3 which calls him Porky, then by all means we will move the article to this name. Opinions? -Stars talk Starssprite.gif 19:43, April 6, 2011 (UTC)


To be honest, I was actually wondering if there was a debate on this topic so I wandered here. Despite my bias in favor of 'Porky' (it makes more sense than New Poke City), I agree with what you said about the name not being canonically official. The way I see it now, someone (I might be able to, if the majority reading this see this as a good idea and I work up the nerve) has to check with the sources who can state that the names are official to settle the debate. My 1st guess for places to send the inquiry would be Itoi's offce (on this part of the Starmen.net site, it shows that someone in Itoi's office knows a bit of English) and then Nintendo of {Insert country here}. They could probably give the definitive answer, so I'm putting this out as a half response to From Beyond the Stars and half question to everyone reading this: Would this idea work? Ant1pr0t0n 05:56, May 1, 2011 (UTC)

Clay Model Edit

Does anyone know what exactly his clay model is holding? I think adding that would be beneficial to the page. (My best guess would be a white bag in one hand and the tail from a Tanooki Suit in the other, which makes no sense.) Ant1pr0t0n 05:58, May 24, 2011 (UTC)

I think it's a bottle of Chocolate Milk that he has in his right hand and a bag of candy in his left hand. I hope that helped!:D User:Pkstarstorm1up 10:52, June 18, 2011 (UTC)

I agree with the bag of candy, but I'm not sure about the chocolate milk...maybe this shouldn't go in the article, and let people think for themselves on this one. Ant1pr0t0n (Talk) 03:02, June 19, 2011 (UTC)

I'm thinking now that it's a bag in one hand and binoculars in the other, considering they saw the meteor and all. Ant1pr0t0n (Talk) 01:31, September 3, 2011 (UTC)
I think the thing in his right hand is a slingshot. YoungOtakuNerd (talk) 01:48, July 24, 2013 (UTC)

References Edit

For some reason, the reference template wasn't working for me, so I had to cobble together something that would work in a similar manner (but viewing the page in code view makes it look terrible). Is anyone good at implementing Wikia's notes on the matter? Ant1pr0t0n (Talk) 15:29, June 18, 2011 (UTC)

AgeEdit

Porky's age was changed from "unverifiably old" to "1,000 to 10,000 years old" during Mother 3. Does anyone know where this number comes from? It sounds familiar, but I can't figure out where it comes from. Ant1pr0t0n (Talk) 01:31, September 3, 2011 (UTC)

Kill or let him live? Edit

Would you rather kill Porky or would you let him live for eternity inside that capsule? I would rather kill him.108.4.13.59 13:57, March 31, 2012 (UTC)Athenstheowl

Honestly, I can't say either way seems fair; ya either take his life or you make it WORSE! Honestly, I'm a pround member of the Sonic Fanon; and my main FC Erica Sakura has a continuity not only for the Sonic series, but for video games in general. This includes EarthBound; in Erica's continuity, after Mother 3, Ness and Lucas ended up opening the capsule and restoring Porky, giving him a second chance. And don't question that continuity; if Lucas and Ness can both appear in Brawl at the same time, then they can appear in Game World. And don't call me a dumb fangirl either; I genuinely feel sad for little Porky, and if I could give him an official second chance, I would. Sorry if this was too long. YoungOtakuNerd (talk) 01:56, July 24, 2013 (UTC)

Id be inclined to cut Pokey some slack due to being raised by abusive parents. Time Travel is a crucial element to Earthbounds history. And it seems clear Ness and Lucas are there due to being snatched from time and even might not be the avrual Ness, Lucas and Pokey from the games and just counterparts. So with time travel, tons of ways can be made to save Pokey and correct his life.Doug Exeter (talk) 08:00, October 24, 2013 (UTC)

These pages are only for discussion of the article itself, not the article's subject. Please take such discussions like this to the forums. Thank you. -Stars talk Starssprite.gif 11:20, October 25, 2013 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki